Filter

Showing 25 - 48 of 300 results

Black JOCK Triple Rush Vibrating C-Ring & Anal Plug with remote control on a blue background Triple Rush Vibrating C-Ring & Anal Plug

JOCK Enhancers Triple Rush Vibrating C-Ring and Anal Plug

$99.99
Illumination THE Plug Illumination THE Plug in a black box

Illumination THE Plug by Paradise: App-Controlled RGB Anal Plug

$89.99
Orange glass butt plug on a white background Orange glass butt plug with packaging on a white background

Glas Cornstar 4 in Glass Butt Plug

$39.99
Clear glass anal plug on a white background Package of 'Utopian Reverie' glass anla plug with 'Clarity' branding on a white background

Clarity Utopian Reverie Glass Anal Plug

$24.99
Three black butt plugs with colorful gemstones on a white background GEMS jeweled silicone anal plug training kit packaging on a white background

Gems Black Silicone Anal Plug Kit

$32.99
Expandable Silicone Inflatable Anal Plug Black inflatable plug with packaging on a white background

Expandable Silicone Inflatable Anal Plug

$43.99
Sport Fucker Scrum Plug Harness - L/XL Sport Fucker Scrum Plug Harness - L/XL

Sport Fucker Scrum Butt Plug Harness - L/XL

$51.99
Boundless Vibrating Slim Anal Plug Boundless Vibrating Slim Anal Plug with packaging

Boundless Vibrating Slim Anal Plug

$24.99
ROMP Luster Butt Plug Kit - Multi Color ROMP Luster Butt Plug Kit - Multi Color

ROMP Luster Butt Plug Kit - Multi Color

$44.99
Lavender Haze Beaded Anal Plug - Lavender/White Lavender Haze Beaded Anal Plug - Lavender/White

Lavender Haze Beaded Anal Plug - Lavender/White

$42.99
A Play 4" Groovy Silicone Anal Plug - Camouflage A Play 4" Groovy Silicone Anal Plug - Camouflage

A Play 4" Groovy Silicone Anal Plug - Camouflage

$22.99
A Play 5" Groovy Silicone Anal Plug - Ocean A Play 5" Groovy Silicone Anal Plug - Ocean

A Play 5" Groovy Silicone Anal Plug - Ocean

$35.99
clear glass butt plug filled with sparkly red crystals

Crystal Delights Sparkle Plug - Red

$40.99
Boundless Beaded Plug Boundless Beaded Plug

Boundless Beaded Plug

$11.99
B-vibe Vibrating Weighted Snug Plug M - Black B-vibe Vibrating Weighted Snug Plug M - Black

b-Vibe Vibrating Weighted Snug Plug M - Black

$105.99
The Beat Magic Power Plug - Pink The Beat Magic Power Plug - Pink

The Beat Magic Power Plug - Pink

$48.99
We-Vibe Ditto+ Rechargeable Remote-Controlled Silicone Vibrating Anal Plug We-Vibe Ditto+ Anal Plug - Satin Black

We-Vibe Ditto+ Vibrating Anal Plug

Boundless 2X Teardrop Plug Boundless 2X Teardrop Plug

Boundless 2X Teardrop Plug

In A Bag 5" Butt Plug - Black Doc Johnson Butt Plug In A Bag 5 in. Silicone Black

Doc Johnson Butt Plug In A Bag 5"

$24.99
Anal Fantasy Beginners Fantasy Kit Anal Fantasy Beginners Fantasy Kit

Anal Fantasy Beginners Fantasy Kit

$49.99
Out of stock
Anal Fantasy Elite Ass Gasm Cock Blocker Anal Fantasy Elite Ass Gasm Cock Blocker

Anal Fantasy Elite Ass Gasm Cock Blocker

$67.99
Rear Assets Rose Gold Heart Medium - Pink Rear Assets Rose Gold Heart Medium - Pink

Rear Assets Rose Gold Pink Heart Medium Anal Plug

$15.99
Rear Assets Multicolor Small - Pink Rear Assets Multicolor Small - Pink

Rear Assets Multicolor Pink Small -Anal Plug

$11.99
Colours Pleasures Trainer Kit - Multicolor Colours Pleasures Trainer Kit - Multicolor

Colours Pleasures Silicone Anal Trainer Kit Multicolor

$50.99

Butt Plugs Collection

Explore our wide selection of butt plugs designed for every body and every level of experience. Whether you’re curious about anal play for the first time or looking to expand your collection, we carry options that make pleasure safe, comfortable, and exciting.

For beginners, discover smooth slim plugs, starter kits, and anal training sets that help you explore at your own pace. If you’re ready for more intensity, browse our large plugs, beaded styles, and inflatable plugs for fuller sensations. Add a touch of sparkle with jeweled plugs or heighten stimulation with vibrating butt plugs that target your most sensitive areas.

Crafted from body-safe materials like silicone, glass, and stainless steel, our collection offers trusted quality and a variety of shapes and sizes. From discreet everyday wear to bold designs for adventurous play, Adult Toy Box has the perfect plug to fit your comfort level and desires.